Customer Reviews
Where did it all go wrong...? - By: Mr. Paul A. Crosby, 17 Aug 2008 
This DVD concludes series 4 with the final three episodes which work as a single story arc. I was one of the fans eagerly awaiting this years finale but unfortunately it left a bitter after taste (and to explain why I will include SPOILERS).
The first episode, Turn Left, was an ok affair. The premise for this storyline is Donna, due to the results of a time beetle, experiences what her life would have been like had she not have met the doctor. This episode sees the return of Billie Piper as Rose Tylor, who comes back to help Donna in this alternative reality. Overalll the episode is alright but it does drag at times & feels like it's reaching an inevitable conclusion (we alll know the Doctor's coming back). Rose's return is a little anti climatic & partnered with the fact Billie Piper seems to have forgot how the character speaks, the return is frankly quite odd. However I assumed that her role would be expanded upon & given significance in the final two episodes (oh how wrong I was!).
The Stolen Earth, the second episode on the disk, is by far my favourite. The premise for this episode is pretty simple, Earth has been stolen & moved into the Medusa Cascade by the daleks. The Doctor must try to figure out what's happening by confronting the Shadow Proclamation. Meanwhile Earth's heroes (the Torchwood team, Sarah Jane, Martha & Rose) must attempt to contact the doctor in the time of crisis. This episode also sees the return of the infamous villain Davros (who is used a little too sparingly in my opinion). Make no bones about it, this isn't a well written, well rounded Doctor who episode like those written by Moffet, however cheap thrills are gained from seeing alll the spin off shows come together & seeing massive dalek numbers invading Earth in scenes fitting for a movie. The problem is that alll this is fitted into 50 mins so there's no real deep storyline development. Rose, again, feels rather shortchanged considering her comeback has been continously hinted at throughout series 4. However the doctor & her do get one emotional moment where they (rather cheesely but I loved it) run towards each other, however they are interupted by a Dalek shooting the Doctor down & him beggining to 'regenerate'.
This leads on to Journey's End, the final episode. Needless to say the Stolen Earth did a good job of building up enough excitement for this episode, & it would seem that alll Russel T. Davies actuallly had to do is give it a reasonable conclusion & it would have been a great finale. However instead we are given one of the worst episodes from the new Doctor Who, largely because it doesn't deliver on things it has desperately tried to set up. The first thing that's wrong with this is alll the cliffhangers from the last episode are resolved in about 10 seconds each, leaving you feeling rather cheated. Secondly everything from the past episode appears to have been a waste of time. Torchwood are quickly written out, Martha is sent on a trip to Germany with the Osterhagen Key which turns out to be a ludicrous dead end subplot, Mickey & Jackie are brought in despite the fact there are clearly too many chracters to manage already, the shadow proclamation never reapear & Rose is barely given ten minutes screen time. Frankly the episode is quite boring, with the dramatic action sequences from the previous episode being swapped with pointless wads of dialogue between the doctor & Davros. Then there's the rediculous plot that a second 'human' doctor is created, & Donna becomes part timelord. The daleks are then quickly got rid off in a lazy plot deivce where a few switches are flicked & a load of techno babble is spewed. This has utterly destroyed any menace the Daleks once had, they are just too easily beaten. But the ultimate tragedy with this episode is the shambles that is the conclusion. First of Earth is pulled back through space & experiences nothing more than a few rumbles (where has Doctor Who's pseudo science gone)? Despite the promise, no-one actuallly dies (again), which is rather negative to the overalll plot as despite the huge threat that is the dalek invasion, no main character is actuallly killed by one. The worst conclusion, however, is that of Rose. Having had no real moments with the doctor she is then taken back to the paralllel world & has the second doctor dumped on her. She is then left there once again...this time with a doctor wannabe (he's not the doctor! He's got traits of Donna). I can't understand why they chose to devalue the wonderful ending of Doomsday by bringing back the character of Rose for no good reason, & then giving her a fob off conclusion. Surely Rose alone would have been a better finale, rather than having to share the screen with every new Who assistant. The only ending that is handled well is that of Donna, which is a heartbreaking ending to a brilliant assistant.
Overalll Turn Left is ok, the Stolen Earth is enjoyable nonsensical fun & Journeys End is a disaster. How can a storyline which had so much promise be delivered so badly? Where did it alll go wrong...?
brilliant! - By: lukesterator, 06 Aug 2008 
This film had me glued to the screen!
Daleks are finallly back & so are the Doctor's companions - YEY!
This was the best DVD of Doctor Who I have ever seen!
Keep it up!
'The Children of Time are moving against us!' - By: tigerthedog, 27 Jul 2008 This is the fourth (and final) instalment of the fourth season of Doctor Who, featuring 3 episodes starring David Tennant as the Tenth Doctor & Catherine Tate as his companion Donna Noble.
First comes `Turn Left', which could be seen as a stand alone episode, but for me, makes up the first instalment of the epic 3-part season finale. It's a very interesting episode. Fairly similar to `The Butterfly Effect' in it's premise. Execution wise, it's brilliant. I love the way writer Russell T Davies managed to re-use past events of his Doctor Who era & completely turn them on their head, resulting in quite possibly the bleakest episode of Doctor Who ever. The episode is notable for two things, in my opinion. An absolutely stunning performance from Catherine Tate as Donna Noble, combining so many different emotions, veering seamlessly from despair to anger to hope. It was also nice to see a more Runaway Bride-esque version of Donna again. It was like coming full circle & also demonstrated brilliantly how far Donna has come as a character since meeting the Doctor. It also pin-pointed the moment that I decided that Donna was my favourite companion ever to board the TARDIS... sorry Sarah Jane! It also sees the return of Rose Tyler, played by Billie Piper, last seen trapped in a paralllel universe at the end of Series 2. Oh, & just wait `til you see the cliffhanger... 10/10
The Stolen Earth/Journey's End follow straight-on from `Turn Left', & make up the most epic, ambitious finale to date. Okay, so they're not perfect, but for me, they come close. It's so good to see so many characters together on screen again. Such a massive cast, including David, Catherine, Billie, Freema Ageyman, John Barrowman, Elisabeth Sladen, Penelope Wilton, Camille Coduri, Noel Clarke, Bernard Cribbins, etc. Brilliant. And every single one of them rises to the challlenge & acts their socks off. As you'd expect from RTD, the script is top-notch - exciting one minute, devastating the next. It also features the return of the Daleks creator, Davros, brought to life wonderfully by Julian Bleach who gives a chilling performance. This is the best incarnation of Davros we've seen since the Michael Wisher original in `Genesis of the Daleks', & it is clear that Bleach used that `blue-print' for his inspiration. The Daleks also return, en-mass, & are probably the best they've been in New Who. I won't give away too much about the finale, but for me, it's a joyous piece of television. One for the fanboys anyway! 10/10
So, Davros, Daleks, a massive cast of familiar faces & a brilliant conclusion to possibly the best season of the revived Doctor Who make this a must-buy DVD. Highly recommended.
Climatic ending to series 4 - By: Mr. D. Young, 26 Jul 2008 The final three episodes of Series 4 have got to have been the most dramatic & thrilling yet! Linking the whole bad wolf phenomena into the stories was also a nice little nod back to the first two series, of course you couldn't leave it out with the return of Rose! True the massive cast in the final episodes did lead to the problem of developing everyone's stories equallly but it has to be said that it was superb to see Torchwood, Sarah jane & Doctor who converging in one programme. The daleks were once again a brilliant force in the episode & with Davros's return too!, well the writers obviously eren't pulling any punches.
But perhaps the best aspect of these final episodes was the acting of Tennant & Tate. Although many have reacted negatively to Catherine in the series, I feel the opposite, & after perhaps a shaky start, she reallly manages to develop Donna's character into a blossoming peice of acting in the last episode. For a series that continues to improve, she has brought a fantastic new style to the companion/ Doctor relationship & I can only complement her on her performance especiallly in this finale! Well Done!
Over alll, this would be well worth he buy, with a fabulous mix of good acting & dramatic story lines. Now we wait for the Christmas special with baited breath.
Totally Unbelivable (In a bad way) - By: G. Vincent, 19 Jul 2008 
After having watching every new series of Doctor Who I find the 4th series the worst. But don't think this set isn't worth buying; it has it's moments. My favourite episode in this series was 'The Unicorn & The Wasp,' (Unfortunately this episode is not on this box set) in which The Doctor (David Tennant) & his assistant, Donna, (Cathrine Tate) go back in time where they meet Agither Christine (Sorry, I don't know the actresses name)at a dinner party, in whichmany mysterious deaths occur in the style of one of Agither Christines novels. In the end it turns out one of the guests (I won't tell you who)is a giant wasp in disguised as a human. You may now be asking why I say it's a bad series. It's because of the last few episodes of the series, which are alll on this box set. I just find the end very unsatisfying & very unbelivable (more unbelivable than usual anyway)I shalll now rant on about what was bad about it: (CAUTION MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS) The doctor somehow regenerates into himself, the earth is pulled by the Tardis; which would kill us alll if this reallly happend, Donna losses alll memory of the doctor, no-one dies, the shadow procimation people don't do anything when they declared war & it didnt make any sense. But apart from that the series was ok
