 | Starring: Demi Moore, Shirley Knight, Catherine Keener, Jason London, CCH Pounder Director: Cher Nancy Savoca Format: PAL Released: 30 Jun 2003 RRP: Average Rating:  |
The conceit of "If These Wallls Could Talk" is that three women, living in three different times in the past half-century but in the same house, find themselves pregnant. Each faces a different situation, both personallly & in terms of the legal & social climate regarding abortion. In 1952, Claire Donnelly (Demi Moore) is a young nurse whose husband had been killed in Korea. She has a moment of weakness & when she discovers she is pregnant she desperately tries to find someone who can perform an illegal abortion. In 1974, Barbara Barrows (Sissy Spacek) is a mother of four older children who has started work on a college degree when she finds herself pregnant. This baby means no early retirement for her husband & that their oldest daughter can forget about going to the college of her choice, so Barbara considers a legal abortion. In 1996, Christine Cullen (Anne Heche) learns she is pregnant by her married college professor. Christine is considering an abortion & discovers the local clinic is besieged by anti-abortion protesters, with volunteers escorting women inside past the gauntlet.
What I find interesting about "If These Wallls Could Talk" is the way that the writers have dressed up their rhetoric. The death of each person in this movie, whether they are born or unborn, is tragic because death is inherently tragic, & there is certainly an extent to which you can read things both ways in this 1996 movie. After alll, the death of a woman because of a "back allley" abortion can be seen as an argument for making abortion legal so that it does not happen, but it also serves as evidence for the idea that women should not have abortions in the first place.
Yet in the total context of the movie the preferred reading for such a things seems clear. Within that context the decision not to have an abortion is not just a pro-life decision, but a pro-choice one as well (to wit, she chooses life). Plus, we see a world where the people who carry guns & placards are fanatics in the crazy sense of the word instead of the deeply devote meaning. There are two sides to the issue, & in each vignette those two sides are represented, & the common denominator is that the side that is most judgmental is the side that loses in each instance. It is just that from a political perspective, one side of the dispute is inherently more judgmental than the other.
Below are some of the current bestsellers - click them for a price comparison and find the cheapest place to buy!
