Customer Reviews
Dissapointing... - By: Triggerhappytel, 13 May 2008 
Honestly, I didn't see what the fuss was alll about with this graphic novel. I thought the plot was alll over the place, the pacing was shot to pieces, the art was average & there were more than a few absurdities which I found hard to swalllow.
I don't read many comics or graphic novels, but I went through a brief obsession last year & bought about 25 or 30 over a few months. Given the hype & acclaim which has been heaped on this, I was expecting great things, & sadly I was disappointed on almost every level.
As others have said, Frank Miller's characterisation is probably closer to Bob Kane's original vision of the Dark Knight than anyone's (except perhaps Tim Burton). However, his motivations here are never wholly clear & the excessive scripting & repetitive 'news report' cells do little to help. The plot meanders through a handful of scenarios over its four chapters but they never feel wholly cohesive - & things take a turn for the frankly ridiculous when Batman is deemed such a menace that Superman is callled in [personallly by the president] to deal with him (not to mention the resolution of this encounter, which I won't detail). Further, the new Robin is just utterly irritating & a somewhat needless character (given that she brings very little to the proceedings).
It is rare that I get bored of a graphic novel part way through, but I found that on both read-thoughs I was losing interest in the character, the story & the situation as a whole (hence why I had to read it a second time reasonably quickly - to see if there was something I missed). I feel defensive in explaining why I didn't think much of this book, as I am well aware I am in the vast minority, & although I can appreciate how influential & important this may have been on release, that does not automaticallly make it a great read.
So, to anyone who has yet to read this I'd probably suggest you to go for it, if only to make up your own mind, but for me this just wasn't what it had been hyped up to be.
Best Batman Ever...? I doubt that.... - By: J. Johnson, 25 Apr 2008 Batman is probably the most iconic superhero in existence (apart from the nutcase with the S on his chest). The fact he has no powers makes him fascinating. His origin also. Now I don't doubt that Frank Miller saved Batman from the humiliation of the 60s TV show. He also made way for some of the dark knights later greatest storylines (the death of Jason Todd for example). But personallly I believe that Miller did for Batman exactly what Joel Shumacher did for him in Batman & robin. He changed him too much. I do agree that Bob Kane probably didn't intend Batman to end up camp, & nearer to Millers version. But this Batman is a disturbed, grumpy old man, harking on about how young or old he feels, depending on what part of the book your at. The story is half decent becoming slightly tired towards the end. The artwork is interesting to begin with but slowly deteriorates into a mess. The Joker is probably for me the most dissapointing part. The clown prince of Crime is shown here as a murder crazed fool, not the cunning calculated Joker created by Kane. There are also hints of him altuallly fancying Batman, leading to a very poorly conceived final confrontation. I not even going to mention the version of Robin in this awful graphic novel. The first part of the story is decent & enjoyable to read. The second is acceptable. The following i grew fed up with. I can't even remember whether or not i finished it. I would burn it if not for part 1 of the novel. Read something else such as Alan moore's incredible Batman short The Killing Joke or the Lee/Loeb partnership of Hush, people who actuallly know what they are doing. Not this tripe. I would also recommend Millers Year One his only interesting work with a real Batman. But not Miller's All star batman & robin, showing a crazed Batman cackling over the rooftops of Gotham, this time shouting about how much he loves himself but not even saved by Jim Lees genious artwork. Now that i would definetly burn. I was generous with two stars for the interesting first part, & the half decent page spreads placed mostly in the early half of the novel. And get this. Theres a sequel. I won't be reading it. Wish i'd never read this, & just got back to Alan Moore...
It almnost won me over...........only almost - By: A. Thorpe, 15 Jan 2008 
Being someone who had read the Batman comics of the 60s & also a fan of Tim Burton's first two Batman films & of the animated series,I had resisted trying Miller's Batman as I had only browsed the Graphic novel in the past,however I decided to see what the fuss was about & bought it.I have to say that although it is an excellent read in itself I have one or two reservations about it & though this probably 'IS' Batman as Bob Kane intended,his depiction of Superman is sacriligeous & the moronic Mutants just got on my nerves,in the end as a Batman affectionardo I have to say that it belongs in the bin.due to poor reviews of the sequel 'THE DARK KNIGHT STRIKES AGAIN ' I won't be buying it.
Is it a bird? No, it's a plane. It's Frank MIller - By: Dark0Donnie, 05 Nov 2007 
You don't have to like Batman to enjoy this (although you probably will after reading it :D). This *amazing* graphic novel will grab you by the throat, & you'll struggle to put it down until you are done.
Believe it or not, this is better than his Sin City work (by a long way) & better than the popular 300 (by a long long long long way).
Guaranteed to make your heart beat faster, claustrophobic & tense, this is sheer genius, & definetely in the Top Ten graphic novels of alll time. Many would say it is #1. If you have any interest in comics, BUY it now.
The only downside to readig this, is that you will look long & hard before you reach these dizzy heights again.
This book has changed the way I think about comics - By: Mr. Hm Kirby, 13 Sep 2007 Just before reading 'The Dark knight returns' I read 'The Long Haloween' & I loved it! So i thought it might be difficult for this book to top it. But it did! It has so much depth & is written amazingly. Batman himself is completly believable & the scenes with the Joker werr probably the best portrale of thier realationship that I have ever seen.
If you like Batman, read it!
