![]() | By: Paul Harding Patrick Horton Amy Karafin Simon Richmond Binding: Paperback Publisher: Lonely Planet Publications ISBN: 1741041651 ISBN-13: 9781741041651 Released: 01 Sep 2005 RRP: Average Rating: ![]() |

Both were published around the same time, & I've used both before for different countries, so I'm happy with their layout & content. However, choosing the right guide this time seemed far more difficult.
Both contained detailed information about the places I plan to visit. However, I found some bits were present in one book, but not the other, & vice-versa. In the end I decided to go for both books. I'm travelling in South India for 3 months, so I thought it would be worth the luxury of having two guides.
Having read both now, I can confirm that both are indeed excellent & each would provide an excellent insight into an amazing country.
Just to prove my point however, here is one example of an item (that I think is critical) that differ in books.
Apart from a smalll section dedicated to 'Todas', the Rough Guide doesn't reallly mention trekking in Ooty, which is one of the highlights of the region. Lonely Planet dedicates just under half a page to this essential activity.
Anyway, I don't expect both books to be the same, & here is a summary of the strengths of each book, I hope this might help you decide which book to buy:
Lonely Planet.
Travelling around by train.
Essential information.
Maps.
Rough Guide.
At a glance section on Highlights of South India.
History of India & its regions.
Food & drink.
All in alll, I don't think you'd go wrong with either guide & wish you a safe a pleasant journey through this magical country.




This said, the Lonely Planet guides are very good for Asia in particular & the South India guide is not an exception to this rule. If you are planning to travel alll over India, I would recomend you to buy only the Lonely Planet India guide instead of North & South India together.
Below are some of the current bestsellers - click them for a price comparison and find the cheapest place to buy!