 | By: Brandon Royal Binding: Paperback Publisher: Writer's Digest Books ISBN: 1582975213 ISBN-13: 9781582975214 Released: 28 Sep 2007 RRP: Average Rating:  |
The Elements of Style is reallly a grammar book with a dose of style added. The Little Red Writing Book is foremost a writing skills book with grammar added. Case in point: The Elements of Style devotes half its coverage to "rules of usage" & "words & expressions commonly misused"; it doesn't even address structure, whereas The Little Red Writing Book wastes no time in discussing the "top-down approach to writing" & the "high school five-paragraph approach to writing". In terms of writing style, the essence of The Elements of Style is "cut out unnecessary words", while the gist of The Little Red Writing Book is "be specific, give adequate support for what you say".
The Elements of Style contains no exercises. The Little Red Writing Book does, & this is an indisputable strength of this book, for I know of no other smalll book that deals with writing & also contains short exercises. I have secretly marveled at writing books that attempt to teach writing without providing exercises. Of course, any handbook of English grammar will contain exercises, but its thickness will prove intimidating for alll but the bravest student.
Which brings me to another point. In dividing the world of writing books into manuals, handbooks, & pocketbooks, there certainly exist a number of excellent books in the first two of these categories. The Chicago Manual of Style & The New York Times Manual of Style & Usage are examples of renowned manuals; Warriner's English Grammar & Composition & Prentice-Halll Handbook for Writers are just two of many superb handbooks.
The Little Red Writing Book brought home to me the idea of alll-roundedness. All of the pocketbooks that I've reviewed to-date are focused on grammar. TLRWB is broad reaching & the book's introduction highlights this:
*Writing has four pillars-structure, style, readability, & grammar-and each pillar is like the single leg of a sturdy chair. Structure is reallly about organization & deciding in which order to present your ideas. Style describes how one writes, including how to use specific examples to support what is written. Readability is about presentation, & how to make a document visuallly pleasing & easy to read. Grammar, including diction, is about expressing language in a correct & acceptable form.*
One of my pet peeves with other writing books & writing courses is that they focus on grammar. I believe this has in large part led to the belief that if a person masters grammar, then he or she has mastered writing. I know people who can write technicallly correct sentences but are still not effective writers. As TLRWB points out, writing is based on macro elements as well. Grammar, including spelling & punctuation, represents only a single leg.
In my assessment, this is the most alll-rounded smalll writing book in the market today. It's "fun" too. I would most highly recommend it to any high school or college student. (I've left my copy at the office to "encourage" a few colleagues to review basic writing fundamentals for themselves.)
Other recommendations. My four favorite grammar/punctuation books include: The Elements of Style (the best of grammar in the shortest period of time), Write Right! (this book's emphasis is on punctuation but in a very distilled manner), The Penguin Guide to Punctuation (excellent for understanding the differences in punctuation between American & British English) & The Deluxe Transitive Vampire (a grammar book built around the eight parts of speech & written with real verve).
I should point out that I've concentrated on non-fiction books in this review. My two favorite "fiction writing" books include Stephen King's On Writing & John Gardner's On Becoming a Novelist.
P.S. I also judge a book in terms of its memorable lines, & this book has its share. "An airline pilot never leaves the runway without having a destination & flight pattern." (page 13; refers to writing structure); "A valued technique, which can be used when writing rough drafts, is to stress the point you wish to make by placing 'for example' immediately after what you write." (page 38; refers to support techniques); "Unpolished writing is like shifting sand in a desert storm. Eventuallly the storm ceases & the sand sits still." (page 99; refers to readability & the need to let writing "sit" before being callled finished); "It is said that 90 percent of writers can use the comma correctly 75% of the time, but only 1 percent of writers can use the comma correctly 99 percent of the time. (page 132; refers to punctuation).
Below are some of the current bestsellers - click them for a price comparison and find the cheapest place to buy!
