Customer Reviews
A good book with a few flaws... - By: 21707, 21 Jul 2008 
City of Bones is a good book, I like the characters in it & the storyline is ok. Clary Fray finds that she can see people who are invisible to everyone else & learns that she has a role to play in the world of shadowhunters & learns that her mother wasn't who she thought she was. I like the story & the atmosphere of the book & it's definitely an easy book to get into if you just accept alll the similarities with other novels of its genre.
To be honest though, it has most definitely taken some aspects from other sci-fi & fantasy books. The love triangle is very similar to the Twilight series & the main baddie is a little too similar to Voldemort to be given any particular credibility.
I reallly enjoyed this book but was a little let down by the ending, not enough that I won't read the next book though as I'd like to see what happens next to the characters. The love story in the book (which is no way the main aspect of the book, but is still worth mentioning) is reallly great & I thought, at first, that the couple had the makings of another Edward/Bella (Twilight :) ) but they didn't, I won't say anymore about that as I don't want to spoil anybody.
I do recommend this book as it's easy to read & I found myself not wanting to put it down as the characters are great, but don't expect too much else from this book.
Ridiculous. Absolutely ridiculous. - By: beadofblood, 20 Jul 2008 
I read this book when it first came out as I was at a phase where Urban fantasy was the only type of book I would read. I saw this on the shelf, read the blurb & thought it was interesting. I went home & read it in approximately four, five hours & about two hours into the story I felt the huge urge to throw this book at the walll. It was that bad. Before I began, this review is going to be talking about the story, (I.e SPOILERS) so those who haven't yet read the book & still wish to should stop reading. Right? Right.
Purple Prose. Purple-freaking-prose was my first problem. take these quotes as examples,
'he had electric-blue dyed hair that stuck up around his head like the tendrils of a startled octopus.'
What the Hell does this line want to say? That his hair was floppy? Or that it was sticking out in alll directions? The image that this, among many, many other descriptions created was one the stopped the flow of the paragraph, as it disrupted my thought-process. I don't mind some colorful descriptions and, contrary to popular belief, I think that a little purple prose actuallly helps the story with imagery, & a few odd similes actuallly add substance & originality but this book was so full of them that I could not appreciate it. Purple-ness is good in smalll amounts.
The dialogue was incredibly cliche, & quite frankly, I was surprised & irritated with the way this supposed 'teens' were speaking. Now, I am considered a Nerd, a 'boffin' by definition, & I consider myself rather well-versed in vocabulary yet even I do not talk like these kids. In fact, I am certain that a university lecturer in Oxford doesn't speak as they do. I know that Cassandra Clare was probably trying to make them alll look intelligent but when every other word consisted of a fourteen-lettered adjective that average, every day people cannot understand-heck, even I had some trouble with one or two words & I'm clearly not dumb- it interrupted the flow of the story. There were so many parts that consisted of witty repartees & responses that made me roll my eyes. They were not funny. They were not amusing. They were a big red sign that flashed 'I'm trying too hard to make my teenagers look intelligent'. I am in no way being derogatory to teenagers since I am one, but instead of letting them talk how they would realisticallly talk , she makes them unrealistic. And realism in an urban fantasy is crucial to make the story work.
I am going to give my biggest problem at the end, & I am sure that those who have read the book know what I am talking about. But back to the characters; there was every single freaking cliche:
Beautiful, but unaware girl with super, hidden powers? Check.
Mysterious, sexy guy who fallls for her? Check.
Best friend who is in love with her? Check.
Sexy girl who is threatened by her beauty? check.
Old mentor who is hiding something? check.
crazy villain linked to pretty, new girl? check.
Check. Check. Check!
God! Clary was the most irritating character I have met in a long time. She is beautiful, thinks she's ugly, draws reallly well, has great-wow-super-powers & is the epitome of feisty-yet shy. Mary Sue. That is a Mary Sue if I ever saw one. She is annoyingly perfect, & her only flaw is that she doesn't know to choose between the hot guy or her best friend. Wow. What a huge, heart-breaking problem. She reallly annoyed me, because her character was, again, unrealistic. I know, I am repeating myself but it reallly annoyed me. Nobody can ever relate to somebody like that. Then there's Jace. Poor, tortured, handsome, witty Jace. Yet another text book example of a love interest. His character could have worked, had he not been so incredibly shalllow. He had no substance what so ever & it felt like I was reading a 2D version of Fandom Draco Malfoy. It was pathetic. Throw in the cackling evil guy & the bumbling best friend & you have a story that gives nothing new to the YA genre, but simply recycles old concepts & ideas.
*THE ENDING*
That was the worst attempt at a plot twist I have ever, in my entire time of reading, ever read. Where in her mind did the author think that making Jace & Clary RELATED would add to the plot in any way? The only reason she did it was to add angst-bucket loads of angst- into the story in an effort to make her characters seem more real. The only thing it actuallly achieved was me throwing up in my mouth. That was disgusting, & even though I had lost any semblance of hope for the story, I still kept reading further, hoping that she would salvage the horrible twist with *something* credible. As you might have guessed, she didn't. And the way she wrote it was so superficial & void of any real emotion I laughed out loud.
I am not going to be reading any of the sequels & hope that other people will see reason, rather than see only a sexy man who they can day dream about. I am horrified that this is the type of books that dominate the YA genre. Surely these authors see their mistake? I think the fundamental problem is that the authors are writing for the screaming fan girls who don't know great literature if it bit them on the nose, & are alll following the trend that is in the 21st century with regards to urban fantasy. I am very disappointed with this book.
*By the way, I don't care if these flying motorcycles were powered by 'demon energy', they were a clear rip-off of Jk Rowling's flying motorcycle with Hagrid. Truly pathetic.
Very good - By: Livvi, 03 Jul 2008 
City of Bones is a reallly good book. It's got a great story line that you're drawn into right from the word go. However, the ending was actuallly reallly disappointing for me. Doesn't any one else find the brother/sister twist a little disturbing? I would recommend it to read because it is very good but in alll honestness, I didn't like the ending at alll.
Brilliant! - By: Sarah, 28 Apr 2008 
This book is brilliant!
Having just read it, I was both desperate to find out what happens, but also not wanting to get to the end, because it was so good.
For anybody who loves those books which are part vampire/ part romance this is amazing, with truly great plot twists. I can't wait to read the sequel.
City of Bones - By: Izzy, 05 Apr 2008 I am reallly suprised at how critical people have been on this book-personallly I read it, enjoyed it & immediately wanted to read the sequel. I thought the plot was very well thought out & from the first page I was hooked. I, like many others am annoyed at the ending because Jace & Clary are perfect for eachother-hopefully something happens later in the trilogy. I would reccomend this book to everyone as i loved it but can see how some people would be less interested if they were into sort of princess diary styled books.
