 | By: Israel Finkelstein Neil Asher Silberman Binding: Paperback Publisher: Diane Pub Co ISBN: 0756776708 ISBN-13: 9780756776701 Released: 02 Mar 2004 RRP: Average Rating:  |
The book is divided into three main sections. After a brief introduction & prologue, the three main sections are 'The Bible as History?', 'The Rise & Falll of Ancient Israel', & 'Judah & the Making of Biblical History'. There follows an epilogue & several appendices that address particular key questions.
Prologue & Introduction
Finkelstein & Silberman begin with a smalll 'snapshot' of Jerusalem in the time of king Josiah. Josiah is a very important figure, as it is thought by many that it was during his reign (circa 639-609 B.C.E.) that much of the Torah & other major biblical texts came into the beginning forms of what we have today.
Following this brief glimpse into the past, the authors explore key definitions of the Bible (what is meant in this book, for the sake of archaeological research in to ancient Israel, is the Hebrew Bible, a book that contains the same material as the Christian Old Testament, in a different order, without apocryphal or deuterocanonical additions), historical periods, archaeological & anthropological ideas, & set the stage for the authors' main thesis:
Many scholars believe that elements of the Bible were written hundreds of years before this time. Thus, the authors have a task to prove their case.
The Bible as History?
The modern idea of history is a foreign concept to the biblical authors. One of the major problems that arises in biblical interpretation today is the application of twentieth century standards of history, epistemology, & ethics to a set of writings whose origin is upwards of 3000 years earlier. The very ideas of individuality, family, tribal & ethnic identity, economy, justice, & good & evil have undergone major developments through time. While it is true that there are timeless elements of the Bible that continue to speak, this is not due to a paralllel sense of history between biblical writers & modern readers. We must always take great care to understand that our interpretations (and yes, 'taking it literallly' is an interpretation, one that was most likely never intended by the original authors) are rooted in our modern times & owe more to that culture than to biblical integrity.
The Rise & Falll of Ancient Israel
In this section the authors investigate the historical record as presented both from biblical sources & archaeological data. Finkelstein & Silberman do not see a unified kingdom as a likelihood during the Davidic/Solomonic period. The archaeological record, they claim, does not support such a conclusion. While many biblical scholars & archaeologists have taken the postulated progression of the kingdom of Israel from one of tribal cooperation to royal unity to division to disintegration as a given, the authors here argue that the northern & southern split was always greater in sociological & political terms than the Bible presents.
Judah & the Making of Biblical History
The key to understanding these writings in the Bible is to understand Judah, the place & people who produced it. Judah is not presented in unambiguously glowing terms, but there is a theme of faithfulness & favour that preserves the inheritance of Abraham for Judah. Judah had always been a smalll & isolated kingdom in relation to the northern kingdom of Israel, without its population, resources, wealth, & international contacts. However, with the falll of the northern kingdom, the importance of Judah increases, and, as it is the origin of the survivors of the tradition, those looking back on the history rate the relative importance in perhaps less than objective fashion.
After examining the development under several kings, the authors come to the reign of Josiah. Josiah institutes religious reforms, based on a 'found' book in the Temple. This 'found' volume is most likely much of the book of Deuteronomy as we have it today. Many scholars believe that this 'found' volume was actuallly written at the request of Josiah or his advisors, to provide a standard model for history & worship that would serve as a more firm foundation for his rule. Likewise, & important from the standpoint of Finkelstein & Silberman's argument for the seventh-century origins of the biblical text, archaeological evidence shows a widespread & sudden increase in literacy throughout Judah, with extensive use of writing, signet rings, seals, & other literary pieces that speak to the ability of the people to produce an extensive literary text like various books of the Bible.
Epilogue: The Future of Biblical Israel
The authors give a brief essay on the importance of the people after return from exile, the brief periods of freedom (yet always under the domination or influence of some foreign power), & the continuing importance of the Bible as formative document for Jews, then later Christians, then later other cultures that tap into the narratives as part of the collective cultural heritage of the world.
The authors are Israel Finkelstein & Neil Asher Silberman. Finkelstein has a position at Tel Aviv University, as director of the Sonia & Marco Nadler Archaeological Institute, & is currently working on excavations at Tel Meggido (better known to modern readers as Armageddon). Silberman is director of historical interpretation for the Ename Center for Public Archaeology & Heritage Presentation in Belgium. Both are frequent contributors to major scholarly & popular archaeology magazines & journals, & each has published a number of noted books in the field of Syro-Palestinian archaeology.
The book is divided into three main sections. After a brief introduction & prologue, the three main sections are 'The Bible as History?', 'The Rise & Falll of Ancient Israel', & 'Judah & the Making of Biblical History'. There follows an epilogue & several appendices that address particular key questions.
Prologue & Introduction
Finkelstein & Silberman begin with a smalll 'snapshot' of Jerusalem in the time of king Josiah. Josiah is a very important figure, as it is thought by many that it was during his reign (circa 639-609 B.C.E.) that much of the Torah & other major biblical texts came into the beginning forms of what we have today.
Following this brief glimpse into the past, the authors explore key definitions of the Bible (what is meant in this book, for the sake of archaeological research in to ancient Israel, is the Hebrew Bible, a book that contains the same material as the Christian Old Testament, in a different order, without apocryphal or deuterocanonical additions), historical periods, archaeological & anthropological ideas, & set the stage for the authors' main thesis:
Many scholars believe that elements of the Bible were written hundreds of years before this time. Thus, the authors have a task to prove their case.
The Bible as History?
The modern idea of history is a foreign concept to the biblical authors. One of the major problems that arises in biblical interpretation today is the application of twentieth century standards of history, epistemology, & ethics to a set of writings whose origin is upwards of 3000 years earlier. The very ideas of individuality, family, tribal & ethnic identity, economy, justice, & good & evil have undergone major developments through time. While it is true that there are timeless elements of the Bible that continue to speak, this is not due to a paralllel sense of history between biblical writers & modern readers. We must always take great care to understand that our interpretations (and yes, 'taking it literallly' is an interpretation, one that was most likely never intended by the original authors) are rooted in our modern times & owe more to that culture than to biblical integrity.
The Rise & Falll of Ancient Israel
In this section the authors investigate the historical record as presented both from biblical sources & archaeological data. Finkelstein & Silberman do not see a unified kingdom as a likelihood during the Davidic/Solomonic period. The archaeological record, they claim, does not support such a conclusion. While many biblical scholars & archaeologists have taken the postulated progression of the kingdom of Israel from one of tribal cooperation to royal unity to division to disintegration as a given, the authors here argue that the northern & southern split was always greater in sociological & political terms than the Bible presents.
Judah & the Making of Biblical History
The key to understanding these writings in the Bible is to understand Judah, the place & people who produced it. Judah is not presented in unambiguously glowing terms, but there is a theme of faithfulness & favour that preserves the inheritance of Abraham for Judah. Judah had always been a smalll & isolated kingdom in relation to the northern kingdom of Israel, without its population, resources, wealth, & international contacts. However, with the falll of the northern kingdom, the importance of Judah increases, and, as it is the origin of the survivors of the tradition, those looking back on the history rate the relative importance in perhaps less than objective fashion.
After examining the development under several kings, the authors come to the reign of Josiah. Josiah institutes religious reforms, based on a 'found' book in the Temple. This 'found' volume is most likely much of the book of Deuteronomy as we have it today. Many scholars believe that this 'found' volume was actuallly written at the request of Josiah or his advisors, to provide a standard model for history & worship that would serve as a more firm foundation for his rule. Likewise, & important from the standpoint of Finkelstein & Silberman's argument for the seventh-century origins of the biblical text, archaeological evidence shows a widespread & sudden increase in literacy throughout Judah, with extensive use of writing, signet rings, seals, & other literary pieces that speak to the ability of the people to produce an extensive literary text like various books of the Bible.
Epilogue: The Future of Biblical Israel
The authors give a brief essay on the importance of the people after return from exile, the brief periods of freedom (yet always under the domination or influence of some foreign power), & the continuing importance of the Bible as formative document for Jews, then later Christians, then later other cultures that tap into the narratives as part of the collective cultural heritage of the world.
The authors are Israel Finkelstein & Neil Asher Silberman. Finkelstein has a position at Tel Aviv University, as director of the Sonia & Marco Nadler Archaeological Institute, & is currently working on excavations at Tel Meggido (better known to modern readers as Armageddon). Silberman is director of historical interpretation for the Ename Center for Public Archaeology & Heritage Presentation in Belgium. Both are frequent contributors to major scholarly & popular archaeology magazines & journals, & each has published a number of noted books in the field of Syro-Palestinian archaeology.
What would be the reason for fabricating excess longevity to the founding of the Jewish people? According to the authors, it was an attempt by priest-scribes to formulate a theologicallly-based ideology. The purpose of this propaganda document was to justify a forced reunification of the "dual kingdoms" of Israel & Judah, long sundered, but still related. Instead of a history written over strung out centuries, Finkelstein & Silberman say the authors of the Torah flourished during the 7th Century BCE. Their intent was to galvanise the people of Judah to participate in the reconquest of Israel.
As the biblical writers put it, David founded a glorious kingdom, further enhanced by Solomon. This empire was centred on the Temple in Jerusalem. A centralised dogma with adherence to a single deity [no matter how capricious] represented by a single building in a central city was the ralllying point. The Torah, then, was little more than a manifesto for conquest & unification. Past failures & successful invasions by Egyptians, Assyrians & Persians were attributed to idolatry, intermarriage with foreign women & rejection of YHWH, the alll-powerful desert god. Finkelstein & Silberman credit the biblical authors with manipulating, if not fabricating past events to build the case for Jewish unity.
The book's authors bring every tool in archaeology's kit to bear in constructing their case. Each chapter opens with a "biblical account" of periods & events. The archaeological evidence is then presented for comparison. The Exodus, for example, a Jewish foundation stone of tradition & celebration, lacks alll support. The Egyptians, meticulous record-keepers, say nothing of large Hebrew slave populations. Pharonic border guardians, ever alert to invasions from the east, apparently missed half a million people crossing the other way. The great infrastructure projects attributed to Solomon were more likely to have come from the despised Omride dynasty of Samaria. The evidence derives from gate construction techniques. Even business makes a contribution - it was Judah's rise in commerce that improved its level of literacy. A more learned population was more susceptible to the wave of propaganda insisting Israel & Judah should be reunited.
Finkelstein & Silberman avoid sinking into the morass of "biblical minimalism" prevalent in recent years. They don't contest the "historical reality" of biblical events. They do insist on better evidence for chronology, & for realistic assessment of the power of Jewish leaders. David couldn't have ruled more than a minuscule kingdom & nobody seems to have heard of Solomon. The authors acknowledge the long-term impact of the Torah & its successors in the Christian world. The reason, they argue, is that no other theological or political documents of the time reached so many people so intimately. Greeks, Persians, Egyptians & Babylonians alll produced their commentators. None of these, however, could prescribe the daily lives of their readers. The Hebrew Bible's writer's provided this & other guides with a surety of purpose other societies never matched. It proved an effective, if historicallly flawed, document. [stephen a. haines - Ottawa, Canada]
Below are some of the current bestsellers - click them for a price comparison and find the cheapest place to buy!
