Customer Reviews
Not his best - By: L. Davidson, 01 Jun 2008 
"Resurrection Men" is highly rated by many reviewers but I thought that it was one of the less memorable of the Rebus books, with recent novels like "Fleshmarket Close" & "The Fallls" surpassing it in my opinion. In "Resurrection Men" Rebus is sent for retraining at a Scottish police academy following an incident in which he threw a cup of tea at his boss. There he teams up with fellow officers who are also deemed to be disruptive & insufficently submissive to their superiors.Together they investigate an old murder case during the course of which many old skeletons from the past are unearthed. As Rebus gets to know his colleagues better ,he finds that they may be linked in some way with a case he was investigating prior to his retraining which concerned the murder of an Edinburgh art dealer. The plotting in this book is typicallly labyrinthine but the pace of the narrative is often slow .The novel is overlong & the story lacks genuine excitement until the final few chapters .
Not for New Readers - By: Sam, 03 Mar 2008 A mug full of tea flies through the air just missing the head of the Detective in charge. This time grumpy loner Rebus has gone too far & rather than being given early retirement he is sent on a refresher course to retrain alongside several other falllen coppers. When he arrives they are given a cold case to try & solve that Rebus remembers alll too well. Is there more to his retraining than first meets the eye? Meanwhile Siobhan, Rebus' police partner, has been left on a case investigating the death of an art dealer. Does the cold case & this new case have any reflection on one another & why does Rebus' nemesis' name keep popping up?
`Resurrection Men' is the first Ian Rankin novel that I have read & perhaps reading them out of sequence is a mistake. The story is a slow burn & is reliant more on the characters & their motives that an actual story. The relations ship between Rebus & Cafferty keeps reoccurring & as someone who has no prior knowledge of their interaction it left me cold. However, I can imagine that fans will enjoy their to & fro. The mystery itself is reasonable, but a little slow for my liking, a lot of the book follows British police procedure to the letter & that can be a little dull. I will aim to read the rest of the books in order so that I can develop a closer link with the characters. However, for new readers I do not think this is a good introduction to the Rebus books.
Can't see what all the fuss is about - By: Mark Russell, 17 Oct 2006 
This is my first foray into the world of Rebus & I wasn't very impressed. Maybe this wasn't the best place to start , but I found the book a tedious read. Somehow Rankin has stretched a thin plot to over 480 pages. It's as if somebody has tried to write an episode of the Bill as a novel. The book builds no momentum, & the last 100 pages drag on as slow as the first 380 pages.
Rankin seems keen to avoid using the words "he said" or "she said" in dialogue so you get lots of "she snarled" or "Gray hissed". He also likes to describe every action the character is undertaking once talking so if a character is picking his nose he'll probably tell you.
On describing a bar: "The place carried an aroma like soured dreams"
Maybe I'm being picky but alll the above annoys the hell out of me. I find it hard to believe people can rate this a 5 star book. But hey what do I know, the guys a best selling author so he must be doing something right.
Excellent Read - By: A. Jackson, 10 Jun 2006 
Ian Rankin has shone again. I found this book completely compelling - i quite literallly couldn't put it down! i would recommend this to any Rebus fan, & if you're not a Rebus fan, why not? Excellent read!!
Rebus Redux - By: johnnybird, 03 Nov 2005 The Rebus Seminar votes .82 red -- John Rebus lives! You only live twice - & Rebus here follows Commander Bond into the deepest cover, as reports of his death prove ...expedient. There is something rotting in the royal Scottish city, & it takes a maverick bloodhound like JR to stay on the trail, & sniff out the quarry. Big Ger makes his appearance, of course -- the question is, what is a retired, hot-tubbing crime kingpin have to do with this affair?
