Customer Reviews
Nourishment for the mind - By: Mr Rob Barnes, 11 Mar 2008 
An absolutely dazzling work. As a recovering Christian I am actively seeking out the thoughts of the great secularists down through the ages.
Particular highlights for me were the writings of Mark Twain on the Church's position on slavery, & also a remarkable deconstruction of every Christian argument regarding morality & God by Elizabet Anderson. Its one of those books that I'd love my wife & my Christian friends to read. Sadly, the bubble of false consolation & cognitive bias appears overwhelmingly strong. My experience tells me that the only evidence that Christians can cope with is Christian evidence. A truly impartial assesment of the available evidence from both sides seems a pose a real challlenge to them.
A vital purchase - By: Mr. R. Lewin, 13 Feb 2008 
Here's a book that will expand your mind. And how could it not? Look at the contributors it boasts: Einstein, Darwin, Orwell, Larkin, Twain, McEwan, Rushdie, Hume, Shelley, Russell, Dawkins & many more. Plus you get a main introduction & author introductions from the erudite & savagely witty Hitchens.
A word of warning: the first 100 pages are a bit sticky to wade through. This is because the book's essays are arranged in chronological order so we start with some ancient texts where the English is very heavy & dozens of commas adorn each sentence. There are some wonderful points made of course, but extreme concentration is required to pick them alll up.
Things brighten after that & the book becomes highly readable. The majority of the essays are informative, stimulating & beautifully written. Highlights for me included Dawkins (as ever), who once again comes over as the world's best science writer, Larkin's stirring poem Aubade, AC Grayling's succinct essay, Can An Atheist Be A Fundamentalist?, & Ibn Warraq's brilliant dismantling of Islamic beliefs. If only Muslims would read it - but if they did they'd likely just throw it on the nearest fire.
We have much work to do. It may be a thousand years before the awfulness of religion is eradicated from the world, but books like this help: they perpetuate the `drip-down' effect. In the West we were well on the way to eradicating it before several million Muslims came to live here. Personallly I doubt that nothing but a devastating clash of civilizations can be the result (we have of course already seen such clashes). Reading this book underlined my belief that this will be the case.
In conclusion, this book is highly recommended. If you only buy one atheist book buy this one (although The God Delusion is also fantastic). In the end you must decide which version of man's evolution & the planet's creation you believe: the views of thousands of the world's greatest ever minds of the past few hundred years; or words written a long, long time ago by people who thought the earth was flat & that the sun went round it, as passed on to them by other people who could not read or write & had not travelled, in their whole lives, more than a few miles from their primitive, parochial townships. I know who I'd prefer to believe.
PS On reflection I'd give this five stars but Amazon don't appear to alllow you to edit star ratings.
Excellent - By: Eric Ambleside, 10 Feb 2008 The choice of writings contained within this anthology is wide & varied, & endlessly fascinating & intellectuallly stimulating. There is enough ammunition contained within its covers to keep the active atheist on the offensive through many a debate.
An interesting feature for me is just how many times in this volume I have come across paragraphs, just sentences even, that by themselves fatallly undermine the entire 'logic' of organised religion. Example: the quote from Mill regarding the monstrous cruelty (and thus laughable improbability) of a supposedly merciful & loving supreme being who plainly (according to the good books, damned in their own words as ever) creates beings by his own hand solely to condemn them to hell fire & damnation. Do what? My other favourite is Ian MacEwan's comments on curiousity being one of the definitions of human freedom of thought, & how organised religions fear almost nothing more - see St Augustine on that one. It's true: the Western religions live in terror of truly free thought, yet without it the human race would still be living in caves. Humanity has advanced to attain astonishing levels of scientific knowledge, yet for centuries it has been a continual fight to achieve it against the squeals of thwarted God-botherers.
Outstanding.
Excellent - By: Dr. S. L. Hamilton, 18 Jan 2008 I found this interesting in that it provides a potted history of atheistic philosophy which could be useful to anyone introduced to the subject more recently (perhaps by Dawkins or Dennet). Some of the historical material can be a little hard to read (especiallly on a packed train) but I found it fascinating to see how the arguments against religion have developed over time. Ayaan Hirsi Ali's story is truly inspiring & is a fitting conclusion to the book. Hitchens' introductions to each chapter are fitting, & often show just how important the individual writers ideas are to the him. Highly recommended.
Intelligent read - By: Claire Heaton, 30 Nov 2007 As neither an atheist nor a follower of a particular religion, I found this book contained thought provoking information. Even though much of it I disagreed with, I believe that as with any good book it should become the basis for stimulating intelligent debate. This book, & others like it, present an opportunity to do as we alll should, which is remain open minded & tolerant of alll viewpoints, & by so doing gain a better understanding of different perspectives on life.
