![]() | Binding: Paperback Publisher: Voyager ISBN: 0006483941 ISBN-13: 9780006483946 Released: 01 Nov 1999 RRP: Average Rating: ![]() |


Each author has a short section detailing their works at the date of publication (1998) before their short story.
Terry Pratchett starts the book with The Sea & Little Fishes, a short story featruing Granny Weatherwax & Nanny Ogg. A pannel of withces want to stop Granny from entering the Witch Trials, as she always destroys the competition by winning spectaculary. The story is well-writen & very funny. Verdict: 5 Stars
Next comes The Runner of Pern by Anne McCaffrey. Not a reader of science fiction, I found this tale to be the worst in the book. It felt a bit patched togehter. Verdict: 2 Stars
The book's second masterpiece is George R R Martin's The Hedge Knight (soon to be realeased in graphic novel format). The tale is set around a century before the events of A Game of Thrones. It is very well writen & sometimes quite humourous as it descibes a Hedge Knight, Dunk & his squire, Egg. Verdict: 5 Stars
Tad Williams adds an extra episode to his slow-moving Memory, Sorrow & Thorn trilogy. The Burning Man shows none of the slowness that plauged the first book of the trilogy. Verdict: 4 Stars
Finallly we come to New Spring by Robert Jordan (recently released in an extended prequel to Jordan's series). The story is actuallly writen quite well, & features the stlye of Jordan's earlier books. A nice addition to a long-fading series that helped to boost fantasy interest to its current height. Verdict: 3 Stars
Overalll, this half of legends is a good anthology. The two stand-outs are the stories from George R R Martin & Terry Pratchett. (The Hedge Knight returns in Legends 2), with Anne McCaffrey being the least powerful story.
I would recommend this book, as well as its other half & the sequel. It does use some mainstream and/or bad authors, but the good outweights the bad.


Reviewing the stories; The Terry Pratchett one is about Granny Weatherwax & is excellent, he seems to be better at short stories than books these days, the Pern story by Anne McCaffrey is also good, especiallly if you've read the rest of them; Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time story details when Lan met Moiraine & is unmissable if you read that series though I'm not too sure how somebody who hasn't read it might feel about it; George R R Martins Song of Ice & Fire story is good but very different in both tone & style to the books. It's set 100 years before & isn't too connected with the series though we get to meet some of the Targaryons; Tad Williams Memory, Sorrow & Thorn story is likewise set over 100 years earlier & is very good.
The first volume ends here but I might as well review volume 2. Terry Goodkind's Sword of Truth story...well I don't like that series but the story is better than the first book (the only one I've read.) Likewise for Raymond E Feist. I didn't like the first book, never read any more but this story is creditable, a lot more so than Magician in my opinion. Robert Silverberg's Majipoor story is good, set just after Valentine Pontifex & showing something of the uneasy relationship between Humans & Shapeshifters after the war. Orson Scott Card puts in a good effort with Davy Crockett meeting up with Alvin Maker & Arthur Stuart. Stephen King's Dark Tower story is a bit slow & a bit of a let down in my opinion. Ursula K LeGuin's Earthsea story isn't bad but I never reallly liked Earthsea (Heresy I know, but there it is.) On the whole, I preferred volume 1

One thing though : when you search for a book callled 'Legends' you'll notice that there are many books with this title. This is why. The first book contained 11 stories. And then the publisher decided to split them into two, so now there is one book that contains 5 stories & one that has 6 (which is this one & was published some months after the other one). It confused me when I ordered the book containing 5 stories 'cause in the description they spoke of 11 stories.
Anyway, they're nice stories, enjoy them !
Below are some of the current bestsellers - click them for a price comparison and find the cheapest place to buy!